The Dallas Cowboys just set a new standard for defensive failure in the most humiliating way possible. A single play in Week 10 against the San Francisco 49ers broke a four-year record for expected rushing yards. Deebo Samuel ran 70 yards for a touchdown while ten Cowboys defenders stood on the wrong side of the field. This was not a missed tackle or a slow reaction. It was a total breakdown of assignments that left Samuel with a six-to-one blocking advantage right at the goal line.
Seth Walder, ESPN’s Next Gen Stats analyst, confirmed the historic nature of the error. In approximately four years, the play produced the highest anticipated rushing yards. Yahoo Sports noted that Samuel started rounding the corner while ten of Dallas’ eleven defenders remained outside the wrong hashmark. The result was a massive 5.7 EPA on the play that pushed the 49ers lead to 31-19. Fans watching at AT&T Stadium saw their team get out-schemed and out-positioned in plain sight.
A Defensive Nightmare Unfolds
The damage did not stop with one play. Dallas surrendered a franchise-high 584 total yards at home to San Francisco, the most ever allowed by the Cowboys on their own field. Rex Ryan, a former head coach and current ESPN analyst, spoke bluntly regarding the coaching staff. Ryan stated Dallas was “the worst coached defense I think I’ve ever seen,”. This unit also holds the last rank in the NFL for EPA allowed per drive for the second consecutive year. This is a pattern of failure, not a one-time glitch.
Cowboys owner Stephen Jones acknowledged the anger from the fanbase after the 46-40 loss. Jones said during an appearance on 105.3 The Fan that he understands the frustration because there’s no doubt that the team is frustrated. He admitted the current performance level is unacceptable. “We feel like the way we’re playing ball right now is unacceptable. Our fans certainly deserve better,” Jones said. The team hired Brian Schottenheimer in January 2025 with playoff expectations, yet they sit at 4-6 after ten weeks.
Discipline Issues Run Deep
Players are abandoning their responsibilities to chase the ball in the wrong direction. This undisciplined style has become a signature trait that stops any defensive overhaul in its tracks. An NFL record was equaled by the Cowboys this season, as they dropped three contests after scoring 30+ points within the initial ten weeks. They also gave up 214 rushing yards on 7.4 yards per carry against a team that usually dominates the ground game.
The upcoming Sunday, Nov. 22, game against the Tennessee Titans at AT&T Stadium offers a chance to reset before the Thanksgiving matchup.
