Dallas owns five players who could fetch a first-round pick in a trade. This is not a guess. It is a cold calculation based on current market values. The team has a massive advantage right now, but that asset list comes with heavy baggage. Owners and fans alike must decide if these stars are untouchable or trade chips.
The Guard Duo Sets The Standard
The interior line is the crown jewel of this valuation. Per Blogging The Boys, guards Tyler Smith and Tyler Booker form the best one-two punch in the NFL. Both were first-round picks themselves, which proves the front office knows how to draft. They are young, cheap, and dominant. This duo alone justifies the high price tag for the whole group.
But the value goes deeper than just the trenches. The Cowboys just paid a massive price to acquire DT Quinnen Williams. According to the analysis, he fits perfectly into this high-value tier. If the team can get similar returns for him, the strategy works. Yet, keeping him long-term might be impossible if other teams want him badly.
Quarterback And Receiver Dilemma
The real debate centers on the offense. QB Dak Prescott and WR CeeDee Lamb are listed as first-round assets. Lamb signed a deal that makes him one of the highest-paid receivers in the game. His contract looks fine when he hits big numbers. However, if he drops back to his 2024 output, that deal could look like a mistake soon.
Prescott presents an even tougher problem. His four-year, $240 million extension is the most player-friendly deal in the league. This contract was a result of owner Jerry Jones mishandling free agency years ago. While his consistency is great, other teams might not view him as a true franchise quarterback. His no-trade clause makes any deal very unlikely, but the value remains high on paper.
Why This Valuation Matters Now
This list changes how the team approaches the future. A first-round pick is a rare commodity in modern football. Trading for a player like Williams shows the team is willing to spend big capital. If they can get that same return for Lamb or Prescott, they could rebuild instantly. But selling a star always hurts the fanbase in the short term.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, as the saying goes. One person sees a star to keep forever. Another sees a chip to cash in for five picks. The Cowboys have the pieces to win now. They also have the assets to win later. The front office must choose which path to take before the window closes.
Which of these five stars would you trade if you had to pick one? Tell us your answer in the comments below.
